Source:: Looking for suggestions for flooring & counter top for 1919 home

Do these things

  • Include SPECIFIC examples of your audience members’ pains problems, concerns, questions, etc
  • Include direct quotes, with supporting details
  • Stick to the present facts — to avoid jumping to conclusions
  • Avoid idea quicksand
  • Avoid prescribing your own solutions
  • Spend just a tiny amount of time at the end, if any time at all, grouping together notes that say similar, or related things

Pain

  • home was vacant for 20 years
  • “is in very poor condition”
  • “needing to put down flooring and counter top in the kitchen”
  • “looking for suggestions for time period flooring and counter tops”
  • floors are down to subfloors
  • need to add more countertops since they are moving the stove
    • wants to stay period appropriate
  • repainting cabinets original light green
  • walls blue/green and clash with cabinets
  • thinks cabinets are from the 50s
  • doesn’t want to be tacky (with linoleum)
  • isn’t sure of the style (Italian Renaissance?)

Jargon

  • linoleum
  • toe kick
  • Italian Renaissance
  • period

Worldview

  • history should be preserved
  • modern != better
  • reply: doesn’t have to be perfectly period appropriate. Be practical first.
  • classy > period appropriate
  • poster seems to agree that practicality is more important than period appropriate as they are considering other options besides wood countertops
  • reply: people in our time are less practical than people in the 20s

Recommendations

  • use same species of wood
  • linoleum flooring in a pattern is period appropriate
  • find pictures online of antique linoleum patterns
  • checkerboard flooring pattern
  • flooring squares were 6x6
  • fill in the toe kick (to make it more period appropriate)
  • zinc and soapstone flooring are appropriate
  • true linoleum is not tacky
  • period countertops: wood, soapstone, tile, linoleum over wood
  • install unfitted hutches for more storage
  • in the period, they were more concerned with hygiene and function than we are now
  • granite will ruin your kitchen; not period appropriate
  • marble countertop
  • tile is hard to clean